Nguttitehen Lodge was formed in 2013 from the mergers of Talligewi Lodge #62 and White Horse Lodge #201 to serve the Lincoln Heritage Council and its camps. Prior Lodges served by the territory of Nguttitehen Lodge include Tseyedin Lodge #65,
Zit-Kala-Sha Lodge #123, Wapiti Lodge #367, Walah Elemamekhaki Lodge #405 and White Feather Lodge #499. Nguttitehen Lodge serves 64 counties in Kentucky, Indiana, Tennessee and Illinois. Tracing our history back to our oldest lodge we are going on 90 years of service to Scouting, to our council, and to its members.
Order of the Arrow Distinguished Service Award Recipients
| Name | Lodge | DSA Award Year |
| Donald Thom | Zit-Kala-Sha | 1961 |
| Thomas Fielder | White Feather | 1971 |
| Dr Carl Kramer | Tseyedin | 1973 |
| Edward Stumler | Tseyedin | 1977 |
| Dr Joseph Buchman | Talligewi | 2012 |
| Harrison Fry | Nguttitehen | 2018 |